A true neighbourhood gem. I will never turn down a chance to pop in and say hello to Mike, Will, James and all the other friendly faces. A great spot to enjoy a Boulevardier made with Signal Hill Whisky, a Crystal Head Vodka Moscow Mule or a grilled cheese sandwich ! Honestly these people are some of the good ones we should be supporting. Make sure when this lockdown ends you go down to Montauk and show support to these legends.

I’m in search of top of the tops cocktail bar and I’m happy I’ve visited Montauk bar. It is cozy inside, very intimate feels, and perfect for a date or catching up with a friend. Niko and the other gentleman were very pleasant to chat with. I had the chance to try the Meet Cutie drink (my fave so far!) and the House Plant (this reminds me of Seth Rogan lol). I was supposed to order Good Grief next but my night’s plan changed. I will definitely come back again and try the other cocktails! Thank you so much for making my night ????????????????

Cozy, laidback spot with super friendly staff and yummy cocktails. Try the Monday night trivia!

Super cute and friendly bartenders, drinks were delish, very cute ambiance.

Had a negative experience here as part of a private event. Bartenders were extremely rude and distasteful to our group and made us feel unwelcome, despite us going to lengths to reserve the bar for a birthday party. On your birthday, you should expect to have fun, not worry about the snobby and judgmental behavior of the bartenders. Drinks were fine but ultimately the place is too overpriced for what it offers.