REVIEWS

(The New Old Horseshoe Restaurant and Tavern)

Reviews

User Avatar
Lisa B
★★★★★

We hadn’t been here for 5 years and have came twice lately. They switched owners over the years. The atmosphere is always fun and the building is very cool. It’s located in Downtown Johnstown which is such a cute town. The waitress staff were all very friendly and attentive. Our food was good too. The pizza was good which I wasn’t really expecting. The Italian sub was very good! They have parking in front and rear. You can get inside from both the front and back of the building. They have a small outdoor patio by the back entrance as well. They also have a bar and outside patio upstairs too! I believe they host trivia and have singers here on different nights too. It’s a casual fun family friendly place to have dinner and drinks!

User Avatar
Ben (Count Benjamin)
★★★★★

The food was really good. Got the 12 inch pepperoni and banana pepper pizza and it was so good and the price is right. The staff made that place what it is. A large group of prom kids came in and took a lot of space. A cook had a family emergency and had to leave. Busy night and a staff member down and the entire team was friendly and the food was still fast. Staff was there when you needed but was over bearing. The music was the right volume where you could hear it but could easily tune it out. Will definitely be back

User Avatar
Emily Bartley
★★★★★

My husband and i were passing through from the vw fest and found this place. Everyone was so friendly. We had a great experience! Thank you :)

User Avatar
Jennifer Evans Cario
★★★★★

I drive from Washington PA to Sunbury, Ohio a few times a month, and let me tell you, outside of fast food, the path is very short on good restaurants. On a whim, i stopped here after gassing up in Johnstown snd im now kicking myself for every missed opportunity to eat here! Friendly staff, quick service and the best short rib sandwich..well, ANY sandwich I've ever eaten. I seriously could dream of that sandwich. Outstanding sweet potato fries to boot.

User Avatar
Sylvia Longstreath
★★★★★

A delightful place to eat. Beautiful building and the food was delicious. Our server was extremely accommodating.

Select theme colour

Stylesheet switching in this demo is done with JavaScript and can cause a blink while page loads. This will not happen in your production code.